Why I'm Not A Vegan - Part 1

I've been into health - eating healthy, choosing healthy foods, staying healthy via natural means - etc. for many years. From time to time, a well-meaning vegetarian or vegan friend will ask me why I'm not a vegan, as it IS the only way to true health - according to some. I disagree, and the reasons I am not a vegan, and probably never will be, are many and varied. For those that may wonder, here are the three main reasons why I don't believe veganism is the way to go. (Note: much of my studies over a number of years have led me to these conclusions. A couple of my favorite well-researched resources are pictured in this post, and you can find links to these and other sources listed below.)

Reason #1: It's Not Healthy.

Cover of Nutrition and Physical Degeneration

Okay, I'm going to get yelled at for this one I'm sure. :-)  But in all honesty, I do believe that diets free of all animal products are unbalanced. Those on a vegan or strictly vegetarian diet for a long period of time must do a lot of planning and supplementing to be sure they are getting enough of a number of necessary nutrients.

Protein: This is probably the most obvious one, but there are a number of non-animal-based protein sources. Beans, soy products, and even some greens like kale and parsley are all high in protein. However, note that none of these is a complete protein source - for that, you need animal products, such as whole eggs. Also, I am not a big fan of processed soy products (or any highly processed food, for that matter, which I'll get into in a bit) - I don't think they're particularly healthy, and although there are some cultures one can point out that eat a lot of soy, it's either fresh soy beans (edamame) or fermented foods, which makes digestion easier on the body, and also introduces some helpful bacteria.

Vitamin D: It's hard to find vegetarian forms of this essential vitamin, but of course there's always the sun! Those who are vegetarian or vegan would do well to make sure they spend enough time daily in the sun (without sunscreen, and with minimal clothing) to build up their stores of Vitamin D. Deficiencies in this vitamin have recently been linked to everything from colds and flu, to osteoporosis, to cancer. It may be the most important vitamin there is for the health of your immune system - and a large percentage of the population is very deficient - even among those who eat meat. Avoiding animal products entirely just takes a further toll.

Vitamin B-12:  This one is imperative for muscle growth and health, and especially for that all-important muscle - your heart! Sorry - there are currently no known plant-based sources of this vitamin. I'm not sure if there's a synthetic version, but if so, I'm sure it's not as well absorbed or used by the body as the natural form. This is probably the most scary and wide-spread deficiency among vegans.

Cover via Amazon

Fat: Last but not least, this one is also important, despite our anti-fat bias here in the U.S.. Yes, there are plenty of plant-based fats available. HOWEVER, the healthiness of these fats is debatable at best. Some are certainly good - for example, olive oil, wheat germ oil, and various nuts and their oils. You do have to take the processing into account though. Highly processed oils such as corn oil, safflower oil, and rapeseed oil (also known as canola) are the OPPOSITE of healthy. Some of them are basically a few molecules away from plastic - which is why in some health journals you may see them called "plastic fats". Since all of your cell walls, and a large percentage of your brain, are made from fat, do you really want to be consuming these weird, unnatural substances instead of natural fats? Plus you are extracting them and separating them from the nutrients in the food that they were made in - and any time you do this you're leaving out a lot of the good stuff that helps them to be digested and used by the body.

Animal fats on the other hand can be easily consumed with a minimum of processing - often simply as part of the whole food that they come from. They often contain important stuff like Vitamin D, Vitamin B-12, and Omega-3 fatty acids. And they're natural. The fat in your body isn't canola oil - it's animal fat!! Doesn't it make sense that your body would  best assimilate and process the fat that is closest to its own type?   (And no, eating animal fat - at least in moderation - doesn't make you fat - contrary to common "wisdom." Dietary fat is mostly burned for fuel - not stored as fat in the body. Excess carbs are what is stored as fat. Just ask any conventional farmer why they feed their animals grain - because it makes them fatter! But that's a topic for another post. :-) )

Bottom Line: If you have to pop a bunch of pills and supplements to make up for essential nutrients that are lacking in your diet, you're eating an unbalanced diet - and that applies whether you're a vegan, a vegetarian, or an omnivore (and yes, many meat-eaters are unhealthy and deficient in a number of things as well, due to not eating enough plant-based foods - I do want to be fair here). But that's a big reason why I don't think a strictly vegan diet is natural or healthy - if you weren't meant to eat animal products, your body wouldn't need nutrients that are only (or mostly) found in those types of food. Period. (More on the "not natural" vein in Reason #3.)

Agree? Disagree? Want to debate the issue?  Feel free to comment below!

And if this post makes you mad, wait 'til next week for Part 2/Reason 2: "It's Hypocritical." You'll love it!  :-)


Sources & Related Resources:
Nutrition and Physical Degeneration
Real Food: What to Eat and Why
Nourishing Traditions: The Cookbook that Challenges Politically Correct Nutrition and the Diet Dictocrats
Former Vegan Reconsiders - Blog Post
Deep Nutrition: Why Your Genes Need Traditional Food
Primal Body, Primal Mind: Beyond the Paleo Diet for Total Health and a Longer Life
The Meat Fix: How a Lifetime of Healthy Living Nearly Killed Me!
Ignore the Awkward.: How the Cholesterol Myths Are Kept Alive
The Great Cholesterol Con